Why the neutral color Palette emerged in Home Decor In the United States: My Theories
Today, when I look at any home decor catalog, or most of the home decorating accounts on Instagram, all I see is a black and white, cream or neutral color palette. Or in most cases, just white. Will color ever make a comeback in U.S. interior Design? or is neutral here to stay?
The Neutral Palette: Trend or Conformity?
When did society become so afraid to decorate in color? When did we become afraid to express our own style and color personality preferences. Or better yet, how did the neutral color palette become so prevalent here in the U.S.?
In order to determine just how and when this neutral style emerged, I needed to do some digging. Consequently, I’ve come up with a few thoughts and theories about this trend, and perhaps you can help me decide which one(s) make the most sense. Here goes:
Theory #1: Keep a Neutral Color Palette to Sell
In the past few decades, the housing market has been hot. Not only has it become easier than ever to buy a home, but homeowners seem to be lacking the attachments to their homes that they had in previous decades. Since they’re selling their homes more often, perhaps they are keeping their homes more neutral beige / white / gray in order to appeal to potential buyers. Do you think this theory could be the reason for neutral homes in America?
Theory #2: The Natural and Organic Movement
Another trend that has emerged in society has been the move toward purchasing sustainable, all-natural or Earth-friendly things. I talked about this in my last two articles about colors of the year trends in 2020 and 2019. From produce and coffee to clothing and furniture, everyone seems to be buying organic or fair trade, and recycling things or upcycling things. This may have ushered in a design style full of natural elements, such as bamboo flooring, plants as decor, or rustic elements. These items tend to complement a neutral décor and color palette.
Theory #3: We are all Tired of Color from the 70s and 80s
If you grew up in the 70s or 80s like I did, or even the 90s, you knew that color was in style — in a big way. There were avocado-green appliances, along with wild patterns and colors everywhere in those decades. People embraced color in their personal (clothing) style, as well as in their home decor. Bold graphics and prints and bold colors thrived in those decades. With color so prevalent then, did consumers need a break from all the color activity, and thus switch to a neutral-loving style? It’s a possibility. What do you think?
Theory #4: Neutral Color Palette is as an Escape from Chaos
Another theory of the white / neutral trend could relate to the workaholic lifestyle we live in today. Our minds are constantly cluttered with information, from our work life to our social lives, to the advertisements we see, to all the social media chatter that accompanies an online-focused world. As a result, could we need a white or neutral interior to give our minds a break? Or perhaps we lack the time to keep our homes clean, so white gives us the illusion of clean and neat? 🙂 Either way, does white give us that much needed relief from chaos?
Theory #5: The Joanna Gaines Influence
Let’s face it. When Joanna Gaines entered the HGTV picture with her neutral modern farmhouse style, she ushered in an era of neutral decor. And it caught on like a virus. At the same time, sharing our homes and personal style on social media was becoming more popular. Why would people not join the Joanna Gaines bandwagon? After all, she has such an endearing personality, and an appealing style, so interior designers and decorators and DIYers alike have followed her in droves (and also flocked to her Magnolia Market in Waco, TX like a pilgrimage). Could she have created an entire trend all by herself? I’m convinced that she has. What do you think?
My Theories Put to the Test:
To further investigate my five theories, I decided to interview a few of my neutral-loving design friends on Instagram. I asked them what they loved about a neutral color scheme, and what influenced their decision to design in neutrals. Here’s what they said:
Brooke from The Merry Morris Cottage @themerrymorriscottage:
“I’ve always used whites and neutrals. I like neutrals because they are calming. And I love the clean look. The best part of decorating with neutrals is they “go” with everything!”
This coincides with theory #4 (clean/calming) and partly with #1 (neutral as a base to match with everything)
Ann from Dabbling and Decorating: @Dabbling_and_decorating :
“I’ve always had a love for all things vintage, antique and wood. That’s where it started. And the white just pulls out the wood texture beautifully. I do love color too though, especially blues. My parents collected antiques for their home when I was growing up in coastal Maine and I took to it from there. But my mother really enjoyed antiques and darker looks, like early American. It’s easy to thrift and flea market for neutrals and they just always seem to catch my eye. I find them cozy. But I do love color too. I like to mix it up when I can.”
Ann seems to resonate with theory #2, with recycling and re-purposing antique and vintage items in her home. When I asked her how she thought the neutral trend became so popular in the U.S. her reply was, “I bet Joanna Gaines and HGTV had something to do with it.” Thus validating my fifth theory.
Kristi from French Creek Farmhouse @Frenchcreekfarmhouse :
“I like a neutral/natural palette — variations of white/cream, brown, black/gray and green. But not exclusively! Our kitchen is a pale, cheery yellow, and I use vintage globes throughout our home because I love the pastel colors. In my office, I use vintage aqua blue liberally, too. But the neutrals definitely anchor our spaces throughout.
This (neutral palette) has really been my aesthetic for about the past 15 years. Prior to that, I used a lot of bright colors in every room. But I found that having my home feel closer to the colors of nature was very soothing. Along with that, I use a lot of natural elements – plants, floral, woven textures, cozy blankets, baskets, rustic woods. Again, this next-to-nature aesthetic is very grounding and soothing to me.”
So we see that Kristi’s approach seems to fit theory #2 as well, with the natural/organic elements. And in addition, notice her retreat from the popular color-filled homes of the past few decades (Theory #3).
My Preferences: Keep a Neutral Base:
As part of this theory investigation, I thought a lot about my own home and how I prefer to decorate it, as well as the theories I had for why the neutral palette is so popular. While my home has pops of color everywhere, our wall colors and flooring throughout are very neutral in color – from warm beige to cool gray.
In addition, when choosing furniture, I often go with a neutral, base color like gray or tan. This allows me to change out the color for seasons or holidays, or whenever as I see fit. I also follow theory #1 in that I know someday we will sell our house, and I may want to keep a neutral palette in order to appeal to more buyers. As an Indianapolis home stager, I also tell my clients who are selling their homes the same thing. Neutral wall colors and floors can help customers visualize living there, with their own color palette and style. So keep it neutral for the most versatility, whether designing to live or to sell.
Consensus: A Little Bit Joanna Gaines, a Little Bit of All of these Theories:
Even though most of my friends who were interviewed didn’t come out and say it, I do think that Americans have been influenced by the media attention of HGTV and Joanna Gaines’ neutral farmhouse style. That is the only explanation of the resurgence of farmhouse décor, and not just the neutral color palette. In Europe, where I can only assume the Fixer Upper show didn’t air as frequently, the color influence in homes seems to lean toward a more bold and colorful aesthetic.
Shop My picks for Neutral Accessories:
My Final thought about the Neutral Color Trend:
I’m personally not one to conform to trends, taking my interior design in a more colorful direction. While I can appreciate a neutral décor style, and I can design rooms for my Indianapolis interior design clients in neutral, I like expressing my own personal style using color in my home. I believe that everyone has a color personality, and I challenge you to find yours. I’ve created a way for you to do just that with my free download, below. After you have discovered your color personality, send me a note and let me know what it is! And if you have a different theory, or an opinion about the neutral color trend, comment below!
— Susan, Color Joy Interiors
What’s Your Color Personality?
Sign up for the Color Joy bi-weekly e-newsletter, and as a BONUS, you’ll receive our special E-Report: Finding Your Interior Color Personality. Learn the psychology of the colors you choose for your home, and get inspired TODAY to start using your favorite colors in your home or office.